Originally posted by ale137
I want to confirm if Craftman needs no Tools also covers the need for time.
If i have Craft(Wine), can i grab some grapes and make wine in a few minutes, or for Craft (Cooking) to make cake in seconds?
A surprisingly complicated question! Craftsman Needs No Tools won't do away with the need for raw materials. Turning grapes into wine with your Glorious Solar Vinting seems perfectly fine to me, but if you were to try and do the same thing with just a handful of grape seeds, I'd shoot you down, because you don't have the raw materials. That distinction is intuitively sensible to me, but I'm not sure if I can articulate why one is acceptable under the rules and the other is not. Ultimately, I'm not too concerned, as I think Storytellers are well-positioned to make common sense adjudications, but I may be able to provide a better answer after thinking on this a bit.